Selling a home is one of the most significant financial decisions a person can make, and many homeowners face the dilemma of whether to hire a real estate agent or go the For Sale by Owner (FSBO) route. Each option has its benefits and challenges. While skipping the agent’s commission might sound appealing, there are numerous factors to weigh before deciding to take this step. Let’s explore the five most common reasons people choose to sell their homes without an agent and whether it’s truly a good idea.
1. Saving on Realtor Fees and Commissions
The number one reason many homeowners opt to sell their homes without a real estate agent is to save on commission fees. Realtor commissions generally range between 5% to 6% of the home’s selling price. For a $500,000 home, that could mean saving $15,000 to $30,000 in fees. This potential for savings is a powerful motivator for FSBO sellers. However, it’s important to note that these savings are not always realized.
Research from Clever Real Estate shows that homes sold by owners (FSBO) tend to sell for significantly less than those sold with the help of an agent. FSBO homes, on average, sell for around 26% less than agent-assisted homes. This means that while sellers may save on commissions, they might also lose out on a higher selling price, potentially costing them much more than they save.
Another factor to consider is that even without a listing agent, FSBO sellers are often required to pay the buyer’s agent commission, which is typically 2.5% to 3%. In this scenario, the total savings might be much lower than expected.
2. FSBO to Sell the Home Faster
Another motivation for FSBO sellers is the desire to sell their homes faster. When selling without a real estate agent, sellers can schedule showings and negotiate deals directly, potentially speeding up the process. According to statistics, about 24% of FSBO sellers were able to sell their homes in under a week, compared to 11% of agent-assisted sellers.
However, while FSBO sales can sometimes happen quickly, this isn’t always the case. Homes sold without an agent often stay on the market longer, especially if they are priced incorrectly or not marketed effectively. The experience of agents in preparing homes for sale, setting a competitive price, and attracting the right buyers is hard to replace. In fact, many FSBO sellers eventually hire agents after struggling to find a buyer on their own.
3. Desire for Control Over the Process
For some homeowners, selling their house independently is appealing because it allows them to have full control over the entire process. They can manage showings, negotiate directly with buyers, and decide on the terms of the sale. Around 27% of FSBO sellers prefer to handle all aspects of the sale themselves, believing it will save them time and effort.
While the allure of full control is strong, selling a home involves complex paperwork, negotiations, and legal requirements. It’s not just about showing the home; it’s also about understanding contracts, disclosures, and market trends. According to reports, over half of FSBO sellers feel overwhelmed by the process and many make costly legal mistakes. Real estate agents, on the other hand, are well-versed in these aspects and can guide sellers through the intricate details, reducing stress and errors.
4. FSBO to Avoid Costly Home Repairs
Another common reason some people choose to sell their home without an agent is to avoid the pressure to make expensive repairs or upgrades. A real estate agent might suggest improvements like fresh paint, new flooring, or kitchen updates to attract buyers. For sellers whose homes are in less-than-ideal condition, selling FSBO allows them to avoid these additional expenses.
However, selling a home that needs repairs can come with its own challenges. FSBO sellers are often more likely to offer incentives like repair credits or remodeling discounts, which can end up costing them more in the long run than hiring an agent and making the improvements. Real estate agents typically have a better understanding of what repairs are necessary to maximize a home’s value and can help sellers avoid costly buyer demands.
5. Negative Past Experiences with Real Estate Agents
Some sellers choose the FSBO route because they’ve had negative experiences with real estate agents in the past. Whether they felt their agent didn’t prioritize their sale, failed to communicate effectively, or just didn’t add value to the transaction, these bad experiences can leave sellers wary of working with agents again.
While it’s unfortunate that some sellers have had poor experiences, it’s important to remember that not all agents are the same. Doing research and selecting an experienced, reputable agent can make all the difference in ensuring a smoother, more profitable sale. Real estate platforms, such as Clever, can help match sellers with top-rated agents while offering more competitive commission structures.
Is FSBO a Good Idea?
The decision to sell a home without an agent depends on many factors, including the seller’s experience, knowledge of the real estate market, and willingness to take on the responsibilities of the sale. While selling FSBO can save on commission fees, it comes with its own risks, such as selling for a lower price, legal complications, and time-consuming tasks.
For homeowners with a buyer already lined up or significant real estate experience, FSBO might make sense. However, for those looking to maximize profits, reduce stress, and avoid the complexities of the sale, hiring a real estate agent is often the better choice.
If you’re considering selling your home FSBO, make sure to weigh the pros and cons carefully, do your research, and consider consulting with a real estate professional before making a final decision. Whether you choose to go it alone or work with an agent, the most important thing is to feel confident and informed throughout the process.
And don’t forget—if you’re looking for a great place to stay while on the move or scouting your next home, MakRealty has you covered with short-term rental options across the country. Visit us today to book your stay!
